Why Did SoCal Air Regulators Reject Clean Air Rules?

SCAQMD’s failure to pass Rules 1111 and 1121 on water heaters and furnaces is a win for gas industry disinformation and a loss for public health.

After 6 hours of public comment and discussion in a packed auditorium, Southern California air quality regulators on Friday rejected a pair of proposals that would have reduced harmful pollution from gas furnaces and water heaters. I watched a livestream of the 6-hour meeting (and provided live updates and commentary on Bluesky). Here’s context and what led up to these public health measures failing.  The South Coast Air Quality Management District Board (SCAQM...

CONTINUE READING

Could CA Local Agencies Replicate Past Federal Solicitation Approaches?

Innovative solicitation & contracting approaches may make offshore wind infrastructure projects work better for communities

Offshore wind is a nascent industry in California, and actions by the new federal administration are threatening to slow or halt the significant progress made in recent years. Despite these new federal policies, however, state and local leaders are planning infrastructure needed to launch the sector in California, including port facilities suitable for assembling and storing massive offshore wind turbines. Some of these infrastructure projects might present opportunities...

CONTINUE READING

Pay to Play

The reconciliation bill has a new approach to try and change substantive law

I posted earlier about a provision in the House reconciliation bill that attempts to effectively repeal NEPA by allowing sponsors of projects to pay a fee to avoid any judicial review of NEPA documents.  That provision is not unique, and indeed it looks like House Republicans are trying to develop a new tool to use reconciliation (which can avoid a Senate filibuster) to alter substantive law.  Similar pay to play provisions exist elsewhere in the bill. For instance,...

CONTINUE READING

Reconciliation and public lands

Most changes would be to the leasing process for oil and gas development and reflect a partisan response to ping-pong governance

As the Senate takes up the House’s version of the reconciliation bill, I wanted to briefly summarize the main provisions that relate to public lands – in part so readers can be aware of the state of play as to what might (or might not) come to pass in the Senate.  The bill as passed by the House can be found here. Overall, most of the relevant provisions relate to leases for fossil fuel development, particularly oil and gas.  Some other provisions are part of lo...

CONTINUE READING

Giving Away the National Parks?

Another Trump Administration idea that probably requires Congressional action, and thus probably won’t happen

Another national park idea the Trump Administration had recently was to offload hundreds of national parks to states and local governments, in order to trim $900 million from the Park Service budget.  The proposal is spare on details, only calling for the “transfer [of] certain properties to State-level management.”  Secretary of the Interior Burgum stated that only about 60 “crown jewel” parks would be off of the list for potential transfer.  As the article n...

CONTINUE READING

The Rock

Public lands law stands in the way of Trump’s proposal to reopen Alcatraz

About a month ago, President Trump floated the idea of reopening the federal prison at Alcatraz.  The prison has been closed for decades, and it is now part of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, managed by the National Park Service, and a major tourist attraction. While a lot of the press coverage focused on the cost and practical feasibility of Trump’s proposal, I want to highlight a legal barrier.  As part of the Golden Gate National Recreational Area, Al...

CONTINUE READING

Abundance and the Seven County case

The Court’s decision will facilitate fossil fuel projects much more than clean energy

I’ve seen some posts on the social media site formally known as Twitter arguing that the Seven County case is a win for an abundance-focused policy – in that it will facilitate more construction of infrastructure by eliminating or reducing environmental reviews.  I think that statement is somewhat accurate in general.  But I think it is much less true when it comes to clean energy.  In other words, I think the case is generally speaking a big win if you want more...

CONTINUE READING

These SoCal Clean Air Rules are Being Smeared

Legitimate affordability concerns are being weaponized by the gas lobby and its supporters ahead of an important SCAQMD vote to encourage cleaner appliances.

After years of rule development, Southern California air quality regulators are set to vote tomorrow on a pair of proposals that would reduce harmful pollution from gas furnaces and water heaters. A coordinated campaign by opponents including SoCalGas is painting these relatively moderate rules as a “ban” on gas appliances and an attack on middle-class pocketbooks. Policymakers shouldn’t be swayed by these misleading claims. At issue are Rules 1111 and 1121....

CONTINUE READING

Government Hires Shouldn’t Have to Take a MAGA Essay Test

Schedule F was bad, But Trump’s latest move is even worse.

The Trump Administration has adopted new hiring procedures that will impose ideological litmus tests in federal hiring. Job applicants will be graded on essays about their allegiance to “America’s founding principles” and their commitment to implementing Trump’s executive orders. These new essay questions have little to do with the jobs of most government  employees and more to do with ideological conformity. I’ll go into more detail below about these quest...

CONTINUE READING

Implications of the Seven County Decision

Possible limitations on NEPA analysis for climate effects and indirect effects

This is the third in our series of posts on the Seven County case.  The first post was here, summarizing the key points of the opinion.  The second post is here, providing our assessment of the analysis in the opinion.  In this third post, we discuss the implications of the case for what have been some of the most significant kinds of indirect effects analyses under NEPA to date. As noted in our first post, the Seven County case has important implications for what ...

CONTINUE READING

Join Our Mailing List

Climate policy is changing rapidly. Stay in the loop with expert analysis via email Monday - Friday.

TRENDING