Do Androids Dream of Endangered Sheep?

Imagine there were self-aware AIs. Would they care about the environment?

With the election behind us, I thought it might be a good time to take a step back and do some musing about less impending issues. Unlike most of my posts, this one is more on the speculative side. The title of this post is a riff on Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?, a novel by Philip K. Dick, which takes place in a world that has suffered mass extinctions. In the book, the remaining animals are now treasured, though many people can only afford robotic imitations. The novel, which was the basis for the film Bladerunner, probes the nature of consciousness and the scope of empathy. Artificial Intelligence (AI) is now a hot topic. Remembering the novel prompted me to wonder how true AIs – those setting their own goals and having superhuman intelligence – would think about the environment.

It’s something of an understatement to say this is a speculative exercise. Of course, no such things exist today. And it’s possible that they never will outside of science fiction. But if they did, would they care about the environment? Consider this a thought experiment. In a funny way, I think it sheds light on some unexpected reasons for valuing the environment.

The AIs might have instrumental reasons to care. If humans are useful to them, they might want to prevent air or water pollution that would cause health problems for their human workers. Climate change might cause disruption to their infrastructure or facilities. Diverse lifeforms might have chemicals that would prove useful, motivating that kind of bioprospecting that humans engage in today. And of course, there’s the possibility that humans who created the AIs in the first place might design-in concern for humans and the environment. It’s equally possible that none of these things will turn out to be true.

Another possibility is that empathy for people and animals or an aesthetic appreciation of nature might emerge spontaneously in any sufficiently advanced intelligence. We don’t know if that’s true, and we don’t know what the goals of the AIs might be. In economic lingo, we don’t know what function they will be maximizing.

Nevertheless, I’d like to suggest some reasons why biodiversity might be important to them regardless of their goals.  As a basic economic principle, the better the potential you have to use something, the more valuable it becomes to you.  For instance, oil became far more valuable when we learned it could be used to run engines, not just processed to make kerosene for lamps. By analogy, as you get smarter, data becomes more valuable.

An ecosystem contains a vast amount of data – all the information in the DNA, plus information on how DNA forms cells and organisms, plus data on all the interactions in the ecosystem. What’s a jungle or coral reef to us would be an immense, dynamic organic database to an AI, and a useful one. For instance, they might find information about complex chemical reactions that could be used for chemical engineering. Besides being far more able to organize and analyze a data set than we are, AIs should also be far more able to draw connections between seemingly unrelated fields.  For example, they might learn things about complex systems from studying ecosystem interactions. This might allow them to improve on their own programming and design, in ways that we can’t foresee.

Moreover, even if “Our Robot Masters,” as one Berkeley AI expert calls them, had no immediate need for this data, they would be smart enough to realize that it could be useful someday, and so would be worth preserving. Why needlessly destroy a trove of data, even if there’s no apparent need for it, when it might come in handy some day? If your great strength is analyzing data, preserving data is a smart strategy. And the only thing we’re assuming about these hypothetical AIs is that they’d be really, really smart.

Putting aside all this speculation, maybe there’s a moral here for us. If beings much smarter than ourselves would value biodiversity, maybe we should also do the smart thing ourselves.  Just an idea.


Reader Comments

2 Replies to “Do Androids Dream of Endangered Sheep?”

  1. “……Ice, the solid form of water. It floats in the liquid form of itself such as your drink. Are you aware that of the naturally occurring chemical compounds and materials, there is only one other substance that has its solid form float in its liquid form? That would be mercury. Science can give an explanation of how this happens, but they can not explain why it happens for water and virtually nothing else. Why is it significant? Because if ice did not float in water there would be little to no life. heat rises so if ice formed in a lake,it floats leaving the things in the lake alive.

    If ice sank it would kill everything in the lake because almost all organic life settles to the bottom. If ice sank, streams would be frozen and would only melt and flow in sunlight. If it sank, the entire heat re-circulation system on Earth would not exist and only a narrow band of liquid water would exist near the equator. In short our entire climate depends on ice floating in water. And if that climate did not exist neither would we. Sit down and look at a glass of ice water and consider that….”

  2. Dear Dan,
    Whom shall we impeach first – Trump or Kavanaugh? Legal Planet must join forces to impeach Kavanaugh first, while investigating Trump and impeach him in 2020 during the next election.

    The American people cannot meekly standby and allow Kavanaugh to get away with sexual assault and perjury, we must diligently proceed and send a clear and convincing message that Legal Planet upholds the moral high ground. What are we waiting for? Down with Kavanaugh. Down with Trump.

Comments are closed.

About Dan

Dan Farber has written and taught on environmental and constitutional law as well as about contracts, jurisprudence and legislation. Currently at Berkeley Law, he has al…

READ more

About Dan

Dan Farber has written and taught on environmental and constitutional law as well as about contracts, jurisprudence and legislation. Currently at Berkeley Law, he has al…

READ more