Subsidizing Fossil Fuels While the Wind Sector Bleeds Jobs

Yesterday, Jonathan Zasloff wrote a post on Senator Alexander and Representative Mike Pompeo’s Wall Street Journal op-ed opposing the wind energy tax credit, which is set to expire at the end of 2012 barring Congressional action.  Yesterday’s post raised the question of how traditional fossil fuel subsidies compare to renewable energy subsidies.

Image
A 2009 report shows that fossil fuel subsidies dwarf renewable energy subsidies.

A 2009 Environmental Law Institute report sheds some light on the “hidden” ways we subsidize traditional energy sources.  The study reveals that tax breaks and direct government spending on fossil fuels totaled $72 billion over the six-year study period, dwarfing the $29 billion of subsidies to renewables over the same period.   What’s more, over half of federal subsidies for renewables were directed at corn ethanol.

Meanwhile, the American Wind Energy Association released a statement yesterday about recent waves of layoffs in the wind manufacturing sector, including almost half of Siemens Wind Power’s U.S. workforce, a quarter of Molded Fiber Glass’ workforce, and nearly 300 Katana Summit workers:

“Uncertainty about the future of tax credits for wind power is forcing the closures,” Katana CEO Kevin Strudthoff told the Associated Press. He said orders for the towers Katana Summit makes have nearly stopped for 2013 because wind power developers want to know whether the tax credits that expire at the end of this year will be renewed.

Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney and vice presidential candidate Paul Ryan have declared their opposition to extending the wind energy tax credit.  Ryan has stated, “We think these tax credits are important to get industries up and running, but we don’t think they should continue on indefinitely.” President Obama supports extending the tax credit and has previously called for a reduction in fossil fuel subsidies.

, ,

Reader Comments

2 Replies to “Subsidizing Fossil Fuels While the Wind Sector Bleeds Jobs”

  1. “Wind” is not a “sector” of the market.  There is no market sector for wind because it can’t make money – period.  The means of harnessing wind energy cost more than the value of the energy thus harnessed.  There is simply not enough energy in the wind to pay for the means of harnessing that energy.  That is not the case for fossil fuels – irrespective of subsidies.  

    Mark G. Rice, P.E.

    From: Legal Planet: Environmental Law and Policy >To: [email protected] >Sent: Thursday, September 20, 2012 5:09 PM >Subject: [New post] Subsidizing Fossil Fuels While the Wind Sector Bleeds Jobs > > WordPress.com >Megan Herzog posted: “Yesterday, Jonathan Zasloff wrote a post on Senator Alexander and Representative Mike Pompeo’s Wall Street Journal op-ed opposing the wind energy tax credit, which is set to expire at the end of 2012 barring Congressional action.  Yesterday’s post ra” >

  2. “Wind” is not a “sector” of the market.  There is no market sector for wind because it can’t make money – period.  The means of harnessing wind energy cost more than the value of the energy thus harnessed.  There is simply not enough energy in the wind to pay for the means of harnessing that energy.  That is not the case for fossil fuels – irrespective of subsidies.  

    Mark G. Rice, P.E.

    From: Legal Planet: Environmental Law and Policy >To: [email protected] >Sent: Thursday, September 20, 2012 5:09 PM >Subject: [New post] Subsidizing Fossil Fuels While the Wind Sector Bleeds Jobs > > WordPress.com >Megan Herzog posted: “Yesterday, Jonathan Zasloff wrote a post on Senator Alexander and Representative Mike Pompeo’s Wall Street Journal op-ed opposing the wind energy tax credit, which is set to expire at the end of 2012 barring Congressional action.  Yesterday’s post ra” >

Comments are closed.

About Megan

Megan Herzog

As the Emmett/Frankel Fellow at UCLA School of Law from 2012 to 2016, Megan Herzog taught and researched environmental law and policy issues for the Emmett Institute on C…

READ more

POSTS BY Megan