permitting reform
Remedy after Remand in the Permitting Reform Bill
Adjusting remedies after an agency responds to a court remand order may help address political and policy concerns with the bill
One of the more contentious provisions of BAAJA relates to remedies. Tribes are frustrated that they will not be able to obtain judicial vacatur of violations of the NHPA – and some Democratic Senators have proposed giving tribes an exemption from the provision that prohibits courts from vacating agency decisions for NHPA violations. That request …
Continue reading “Remedy after Remand in the Permitting Reform Bill”
CONTINUE READINGWeighing the permitting reform bill
A summary of what I think the main changes to enviro law are, and the risks of uncertainty in how it is applied
Based on the manager’s amendment, and assessing the bill as it stands, here is my key summary of what I think the major components of Titles I through IV do overall: Eliminate supplemental NEPA based on new information (though it is retained for changes in projects). Narrow alternatives to be considered under NEPA where there …
Continue reading “Weighing the permitting reform bill”
CONTINUE READINGThe revised permitting reform bill
Amendments announced over the weekend address some key issues, but leave others unresolved
The manager’s amendments for BAAJA – the changes to the bill that the primary drafters support – came out Saturday morning. Given the short time frame (the first procedural vote is tomorrow morning), this will have to be a quick overview of those changes and their implications. I’ll cover the extent to which those changes …
Continue reading “The revised permitting reform bill”
CONTINUE READINGIs Permit Certainty Worth It?
The most problematic provision in the permitting reform bill is permit certainty. It’s not even clear it will accomplish what it sets out to do.
I’ve written a bunch about the issues with the permit certainty provisions of the permitting reform bill. Apparently that provision was a demand of Democratic negotiators, seeking to protect renewable energy from the Trump Administration. If that is the goal, it comes at a steep cost in terms of an overbroad provision with lots of …
Continue reading “Is Permit Certainty Worth It?”
CONTINUE READINGPodesta Is Right
Permitting reform bill asymmetrically makes it easier to grant permits than revoke them. That could have sweeping consequences.
At the end of the last week, these comments from John Podesta, a major Democratic Party policy operative, got some attention. He called the permitting reform bill a “loaded howitzer” in the hands of President Trump, should it be enacted as it is currently written. In particular, Podesta argued that the permitting certainty provisions would …
Continue reading “Podesta Is Right”
CONTINUE READINGWhat’s Left of NEPA?
It’s already taken three major blows. Yet opponents seem to fear it as much as ever.
In effect, NEPA has been poisoned, bludgeoned, and stabbed in succession by the three branches of government. You would think that NEPA reform might seem less urgent after all that. Yet permit reformer still seem to think it’s as dangerous as ever, like a vampire that can only be killed by a wooden stake through the heart at midnight.
CONTINUE READINGProcedure Versus Substance
Drawing a false dichotomy between procedure and substance does not lead to good policy
“If I let you write the substance and you let me write the procedure, I’ll screw you every time.” Former US Rep. Dingell In the prior post I criticized some of the positions of environmental groups in the debates over the Senate permitting reform bill. But advocates of the bill have also made problematic arguments. …
Continue reading “Procedure Versus Substance”
CONTINUE READINGPermitting Wars
Environmental groups should engage constructively with permitting reform
The permitting reform bill now being considered in the Senate has provoked fairly vicious fights between “abundance” advocates and at least some environmental groups. I think that there are valid critiques of many of the arguments that each side is making, and I think unpacking those critiques can be helpful in trying to find a …
Continue reading “Permitting Wars”
CONTINUE READINGHow to Deconstruct Federal Regulation
Section 1401 of the Permitting Reform Bill is a stealth repeal of a wide swath of federal regulatory law, not just environmental law
I want to write separately to emphasize how sweeping the permit certainty provisions of Section 1401 of the permitting reform bill likely are. Again, these are provisions that apply if an agency takes an “action” (which is undefined) against a “project” (also undefined) that “would revoke, rescind, withdraw, terminate, suspend, amend, or alter a Federal …
Continue reading “How to Deconstruct Federal Regulation”
CONTINUE READINGImproving permitting reform
Suggestions to make the permitting reform bill work better and avoid unintended results
I’ve written a bunch about the Senate’s permitting reform bill. My basic takeaway is that I want this bill to pass, but that there are some serious flaws in the bill, particularly in the permit certainty provisions, that must be addressed. And in general, there are areas where greater clarity about the scope of the …
Continue reading “Improving permitting reform”
CONTINUE READING



