public lands

Is Permit Certainty Worth It?

The most problematic provision in the permitting reform bill is permit certainty. It’s not even clear it will accomplish what it sets out to do.

I’ve written a bunch about the issues with the permit certainty provisions of the permitting reform bill. Apparently that provision was a demand of Democratic negotiators, seeking to protect renewable energy from the Trump Administration. If that is the goal, it comes at a steep cost in terms of an overbroad provision with lots of …

CONTINUE READING

Podesta Is Right

Permitting reform bill asymmetrically makes it easier to grant permits than revoke them. That could have sweeping consequences.

At the end of the last week, these comments from John Podesta, a major Democratic Party policy operative, got some attention.  He called the permitting reform bill a “loaded howitzer” in the hands of President Trump, should it be enacted as it is currently written.  In particular, Podesta argued that the permitting certainty provisions would …

CONTINUE READING

Strictly Ballroom

A man in a suit and red tie holds a large photograph of classical columns at a construction site with unfinished structures and trees in the background.

How will the Supreme Court’s opinion impact environmental standing?

There’s a lot of concern about how the Supreme Court’s opinion in the ballroom case could impact environmental law.  In the majority’s view, the problem was that the plaintiff lacked standing.  The concern is that the Court may have cut back standing doctrine in a way that will block many environmental cases.  You never know what the Court might do down the road, but I think the opinion itself is much more limited.

CONTINUE READING

Wildfire and National Forests

Reforming federal forest management to address wildfire

This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF.  The draft article this blog post series is based is here. This is the third in a series of blog posts on our proposal to reform wildfire law in the United States.  The first post is here.  The second post is here. Federally …

CONTINUE READING

Fixing Wildfire Law

The urgent challenge of reforming how we manage wildfire

This blog post was co-authored with Dave Owen, at UC Law SF.  The draft article this blog post series is based is here. Every year brings another reminder of why fire is at the top of environmental and natural resource issues for the United States, and how our legal system struggles to adjust to fire. …

CONTINUE READING

America the Beautiful — Not Beautification Projects

A split image shows the Lincoln Memorial and the Washington Monument reflected clearly in a large puddle on the ground, with the sky and clouds mirrored in the water.

The Drain is a weekly roundup of environmental and climate news from Legal Planet.

If you braved one of America’s most iconic national parks this weekend, you may have a new appreciation for the meaning of Jean-Paul Sartre’s famous line that “hell is other people.”  At Yosemite, visitors reported waiting up to two hours just to enter the park and once they made it through, they were greeted by …

CONTINUE READING

Building Bridges Over Troubled Waters

Building Bridges Over Troubled Waters

There are environmental issues that span the partisan divide, even today.

It turns out that the solar industry has two allies in unlikely places: Trump stalwarts Kellyanne Conway and Katie Miller (the wife of Stephen Miller).  This is a reminder that, even in an era of hyper-partisanship, it is sometimes possible to create alliances across the ideological gulf.Despite polarization, there are some environmental issues that can bridge the partisan gap. T Some issues, like climate change, have become deeply polarizing. We shouldn’t give up on those, but we should also pay attention to issues that have greater potential for reaching out to Trump supporters.

CONTINUE READING

How to Create Permit Certainty?

What might be a good path forward for the FREEDOM Act?

This is the third post in a series looking at the most recent proposed legislation for permit certainty, the FREEDOM Act.  Part one, discussing why Congress is considering permit certainty and its importance, is here.  Part two, analyzing the strengths and weaknesses of the bill, is here. The good parts of the bill – making …

CONTINUE READING

Analyzing the FREEDOM Act

Permit certainty bill has beneficial judicial review provisions, but problematic provisions for damages and compensation.

This is the second post in a series on the FREEDOM Act, a bill in the House of Representatives to address the issue of permit certainty.  Part one, explaining why permit certainty is now a hot topic in Congress, is here. All of the reforms in the FREEDOM  Act turn on the creation of a …

CONTINUE READING

The FREEDOM Act and Permit Certainty

Permit certainty bill has potential, but also some problems that could make it unworkable

As one advocate for permitting reform aptly noted, “permit certainty” is now a prerequisite for any action on permitting reform in this Congress.  That’s because the Trump Administration’s war on renewable energy means that Democrats have no desire to do a deal that would not, in practice, make a difference for investment in new clean …

CONTINUE READING

Join Our Mailing List

Climate policy is changing rapidly. Stay in the loop with expert analysis via email Monday - Friday.

Join Our Mailing List

The Drain is a roundup of climate and environmental news from Legal Planet delivered to your Inbox once a week.

The Drain

TRENDING