Indian Federalism and Climate Change

Federalism is a hot topic (so to speak) for scholars working on climate change, but we have so far remained resolutely at home, focusing solely on American federalism.  It’s now time to start thinking about how federalism might impact India, which has maintained a federal system for more than 60 years, and has decentralized greatly in recent years.

How might we do this?  Here’s a hypothesis:

Scholars of India’s response to globalization have long recognized that federalism might advance a global liberal agenda because of the differing comparative and absolute advantages of Indian states.  For example, Karnataka, the center of India’s technology and software industries, will tend to support more liberalizing policies than backward, corrupt, and largely agricultural Uttar Pradesh.  And this gets translated into national policy, as state governments and regional parties use their political muscle to effect changes at the national level.

We can translate this into the climate area by observing that climate mitigation and adaptation policies will have very different effects in different regions, and — importantly — these policies might contain significant comparative economic advantages for different states.  Too much of the climate discourse has focused on the regulations and taxes that will be necessary to combat climate change.  But of course there are important growth opportunities there as well.

For example, the Deccan plain in the heart of the country gets consistent sunshine all year with the exception of the monsoon.  That means that policies that favor solar energy might present an opportunity for those states.  Now, this doesn’t always work: it’s not like North Dakotans are excited about Waxman-Markey because their whole state can be turned into a wind farm (although they probably should be).  The endowment effect is playing its role, and they are more concerned about giving agriculture a sweetheart deal.

But if we drill down into the economic potential of climate policy apart from particular subsidies (which really in some cases amount to buying off key constituencies), we may be able to put together a political economy strategy that will work for India.  Adaptation technologies, for example, might be better produced or developed in some geographic areas than others.   I’d be willing to bet, however, that those areas have no idea who they are.  It’s up to scholars to start letting them know.

India will not enact anything like national climate legislation any time soon.  The task, as always, is to build it up by stages (and hope that we have enough time to do so!).  Using the political economy of federalism is a potentially fruitful way to develop the emerging domestic constituencies to bend the Indian emissions curve.

, , ,

Reader Comments

One Reply to “Indian Federalism and Climate Change”

  1. The One and Only One Solution of Climate Change and Biodiversity – The United World.

    The United World.
    The Uni-Rule World.

    Solution all in one.
    Solution all in built.

    Knowledgeable New Born.

    Un-known all Blow Horn.
    World Drama Own version.

    No Win Close Curtain.
    Rehearsal On No-Learn.

    Wishing Dear Mother Earth.
    Many Returns Of The Death.

    Flying lovers Copenhagen.
    Roaming climate romance.

    Curiously lost the track.
    Open battle game war.

    Traps/tricks counter act.
    Wisdom voice back track.

    How to open the heart?
    Where the natural love.

    What someone would say?
    Lost that your mind.

    Found free and fresh.
    Memory access upgrade.

    No hang up No disk crash.
    Sectors along all intact.

    No pressure no sugar.
    Smartly moving graphs.

    Revision Report short vision.

    Simplicity too evident.
    Complexity un-designed.

    Sure insure yes we can.
    Change the world even.

    Climate lovers Copenhagen.
    Climate lovers earth around.

    Found Aladdin magic lamp.
    Un-served anything no camp.

    Knowledgeable New Born.

    Solution all in built.
    Solution all in one.

    The United World.
    The Uni-Rule World.

    Anything Else Treat With Patch.
    Mind Business No Record Match.

    Good Ground Develop Addition.
    Mourn Meet Shame Celebration.

    Super Human Life Worth.
    Expect Earth Early Death.

    Nothing Left On Write Will.
    Most-Wanted Mother Deal.

    Well With In Millennium.
    Slow But Certain Death.

    The One and The Only One.
    The Solution To Every One.

    World Surprise United Other Ways.
    Select Selfish Path Mislead All-Ways.

    Success So Far Many Times.
    Realize Fact Once Right Time.

    Solution all in one.
    Solution all in built.

    The United World.
    The Uni-Rule World.

    Hari Kotadia.

Comments are closed.

About Jonathan

Jonathan Zasloff teaches Torts, Land Use, Environmental Law, Comparative Urban Planning Law, Legal History, and Public Policy Clinic – Land Use, the Environment and Loc…

READ more

About Jonathan

Jonathan Zasloff teaches Torts, Land Use, Environmental Law, Comparative Urban Planning Law, Legal History, and Public Policy Clinic – Land Use, the Environment and Loc…

READ more

POSTS BY Jonathan