permitting reform

The FREEDOM Act and Permit Certainty

Permit certainty bill has potential, but also some problems that could make it unworkable

As one advocate for permitting reform aptly noted, “permit certainty” is now a prerequisite for any action on permitting reform in this Congress.  That’s because the Trump Administration’s war on renewable energy means that Democrats have no desire to do a deal that would not, in practice, make a difference for investment in new clean …

CONTINUE READING

The details of SEQRA reform

Looking at the specifics of how New York’s SEQRA reform efforts would work

I recently posted about proposed legislation in New York, advanced by the governor, to reform the state’s environmental review law (the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA)) to facilitate infill housing – an approach similar to what California did last year.  There’s now legislative text (available here) available to allow a close review of what …

CONTINUE READING

SEQRA Reform

No, not CEQA, SEQRA. New York appears to be following California’s lead in overhauling state-level environmental review.

New York Governor Hochul this week proposed amendments to New York’s State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA).  The press release has a breathless title: “Let Them Build.”  But the proposal itself appears to be very similar to what California just enacted.  Housing projects in already developed areas, along with some other similar projects, such as …

CONTINUE READING

Creating Lease Certainty

There are some steps Congress could take to increase certainty for energy leases on federal lands, but there will be tradeoffs.

As my prior two posts noted, there are substantial legal authorities that allow an executive to suspend or cancel leases for energy development.  In the case of on-shore leases, that power might be extremely broad.  And with an Administration that appears to use its powers to pursue political grudges and to push the envelope on …

CONTINUE READING

Canceling Onshore Leases

The executive may have broad authority to cancel onshore leases, perhaps even without compensation. Congress might want to fix that.

My last post covered the likely power that the Administration has to cancel off-shore leases for wind projects – a power that it probably has, if it was to ever get its act together.  But even though the Administration has not yet used it, I think it probably has even broader power to cancel leases …

CONTINUE READING

Can They Do That?

The feds probably do ultimately have the authority to shut down offshore wind farms – if they ever get their act together.

This week, three different offshore wind projects that were targeted with shutdown orders by the Trump Administration won preliminary injunctions against those orders.  Those lawsuits are in response to a blanket order in December from the Trump Administration, issuing stop work orders to all off-shore wind projects in the United States.  (For some projects, this …

CONTINUE READING

On the theory of permitting certainty

It’s a hard problem to solve. There might be lessons from housing and land-use.

What is being called “permitting certainty” is now a central component of any permitting reform that might pass through this Congress.  Permitting certainty is the concept of making it harder for the Executive Branch to capriciously revoke permits based on personal grudges, political vendettas, or other factors that Congress does not wish to be the …

CONTINUE READING

Veto trouble

Trump’s veto of consensus legislation is trouble for future bipartisan permitting reform.

This week, President Trump vetoed two pieces of legislation, his first vetoes of his second term.  There were two unusual points about these vetoes – even for this Administration.  First, the bills in question were small, local matters.  One bill involved a water project to benefit rural southeastern Colorado.  The other bill expanded the scope …

CONTINUE READING

Poisoning the well

Trump Administration “pause” on offshore wind projects undermines prospect of permitting deal

Yesterday, the Trump Administration announced that it was “pausing” construction for the five major offshore wind projects on the East Coast, based on “national security” grounds – because of the possibility that wind turbines can interfere with radar operations. This announcement is, to say the least, not helpful for current permitting reform discussions.  It emphasizes …

CONTINUE READING

NEPA Reform and Transmission

Reducing NEPA compliance alone won’t solve our transmission problems, and it might be a bad deal for the climate

The recent passage of the SPEED Act highlights one angle in current permitting reform debates: A focus on NEPA, which as a procedural statute might be more feasible to reform than other substantive statutes. Advocates for the SPEED Act have argued that it will help with a range of infrastructure projects, including transmission. But a …

CONTINUE READING

Join Our Mailing List

Climate policy is changing rapidly. Stay in the loop with expert analysis via email Monday - Friday.

Join Our Mailing List

The Drain is a roundup of climate and environmental news from Legal Planet delivered to your Inbox once a week.

The Drain

TRENDING