What’s Left of NEPA?
It’s already taken three major blows. Yet opponents seem to fear it as much as ever.
NEPA seems to be everyone’s favorite punching bag this days. One major focus of the Senate’s permitting bill is to cut back on remedies for NEPA violations. The bill would generally allow projects to proceed even though their environmental impact statements are seriously flawed. The funny thing is that the drive to prune NEPA seems unabated even though the statute itself was dramatically weakened three times in the past three years.
First, Congress took a bite out of NEPA with the 2023 BUILDER Act, which was part of the debt ceiling deal that Biden negotiated with Congress. It’s a poorly drafted law, though some of it seemed to more or less follow existing practices. But it did make some significant changes. It narrowed the definition of the major federal projects that are subject to NEPA. It also expanded the use of categorical exclusions, a procedure that allows agencies to exempt projects from NEPA. In addition, it placed time limits on environmental reviews and imposed page limits on the resulting documents to limit their scope and complexity, while also authorizing project applicants to draft the reviews of their own projects.
Second, in 2025, the Trump Administration abolished the regulations that had governed the NEPA process for nearly fifty years. Those regulations were issued by the Council on Environmental Quality in the White House. They had provided a detailed framework that courts could turn to in deciding NEPA cases. The CEQ regulations were replaced by agency-by-agency rules that are often incomplete, difficult to access, and subject to change. As a result, courts have lost the yardstick that they used to measure NEPA compliance.
Third, the Supreme Court decided to pile on in the Seven County case. The majority opinion claimed that NEPA had caused delay after delay in projects with Kafkaesque procedural demands from courts. The Court hurried to the rescue. It cut back on the scope of environmental reviews, excusing agencies from considering environmental impacts that are inevitable but indirect. And finally, the Court emphasized that the “the bedrock principle of judicial review in NEPA cases can be stated in a word: Deference.” In short, the Court was sending a message that lower courts should bend over backwards to reject challenges to environmental impact statements.
In effect, NEPA has been poisoned, bludgeoned, and stabbed in succession by the three branches of government. You would think that NEPA reform might seem less urgent after all that. Yet permit reformers still seem to think it’s as dangerous as ever, like a vampire that can only be killed by a wooden stake through the heart at midnight.





Yes, NEPA is on life support with the Republicans, or whatever they are called now, ready to pull the plug. They must feel they lack 60 votes in the Senate to repeal it or they probably would. Back in 1968 when NEPA was conceived the President and Congress cared about environmental quality. They do not now. Back then it was inconceivable that a sitting president would not “take care that the laws be faithfully executed.” The rule of law mattered more then, unlike today.
Congress has no explicit constitutional authority to legislate environmental policy. But Congress and the president do have authority to define and direct what Federal agencies do. Neither Congress nor the courts can determine the president’s interests or priorities. NEPA’s implementation depends on how the president directs the Executive Office of the President—especially the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ)—and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Various agencies administer specific aspects of environmental policy, but NEPA is the nation’s umbrella environmental statute, and CEQ and EPA oversee it in theory. Both agencies still exist, but their NEPA roles have been greatly reduced in an administration that cares little for environmental quality or the life sustaining systems NEPA was designed to protect. I used to say NEPA’s problems stemmed from “judicial misconstruction, legislative indifference, and executive neglect.” Now I say it is from ignorance in the Supreme Court, Congressional malpractice, and Presidential tampering. I’m not yet giving up on NEPA, and I am more convinced than ever that it has a substantive role that is still viable.
Actually, it was the public who cared about the environment, and probably some Congresspersons. Richard Nixon was pressured to accept environmental laws; he did not sign them enthusiastically. It is time for us to push our politicians again; maybe this Election Day will help.
There’s that. The Santa Barbara oil spill and the infamous Cuyahoga River fire energized a public that was tired of the Vietnam War and wanted to see changes here at home. Still, the Senate unanimously passed NEPA, and the House vote was 372 to 15 with 43 not voting. Nixon did not care deeply about environmental quality even though he signed major environmental legislation. Nixon realized the youth vote would be swayed by the environmental legislation he signed such as NEPA, the Endangered Species Act, Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Marine Mammal Protection Act, and the Safe Drinking Water Act. In addition, he created the EPA, CEQ (which was part of NEPA), and NOAA.